Appraisers work on a confidential basis with their clients (known as a client-appraiser relationship) and have a fiduciary duty to their client similar to that of other professionals such as lawyers and accountants.
Under the AIC’s Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, any discussions on or disclosure of information contained in an appraisal report must be done with the written consent of the appraiser’s client.
Often when a report is completed for mortgage lending purposes, the homeowner is required to pay the appraisal fee but the appraiser’s client is the lending institution making a lending decision for the property based on the report. The lender provides instructions to the AIC member regarding how the report is to be completed.
AIC members are required to comply with the AIC’s standards of professional practice (CUSPAP). CUSPAP requires an AIC member to maintain the confidential nature of their relationship with their client. The AIC member will need written authorization from the lender – their client – to release the report to any third party – including the person who paid for the report. Only the AIC member’s client and any intended user identified in the report are authorized to receive a copy of and rely on the report. Because the AIC member is the author of the report, consent to release must also be obtained from the AIC member.
The homeowner is the lender’s client. You may wish to ask your lender what the lender’s policies and practices are regarding whether or not you (the lender’s client) will pay for the report to be performed, and/or get a copy of that report regardless of whether the loan is approved or denied. This is a business decision by your lender/mortgage broker. An AIC appraiser would not be aware of this information or of any arrangements made between your lender and you – their client.